ATW hasn't been reformulated as far as I can tell, I've had a bunch of products in this scent over the years, and I wore it a lot in 2019-2020 in particular. to my nose, they both share the scent of raspberries and patchouli (even though it's not listed in ATW).

I've smelled this numerous times at bath and body works and I've always passed it off as "okay" or "eh, I don't like it all that much". keep in mind that although this one is really popular, there isn't anything unique about it besides it just smells really good, in a warm, comforting, non-sweet-or-cloying way. I would say that if you love peony and citrus (it smells citrusy to me) but also warm and sugary without being overpowering, this would be something you'd like. When compared with popular fragrances like Versace Bright Crystal, LVEB, celebrity perfumes, and a few others, it's quite decidedly adult.I personally think it'll be on its best in both spring and summer - compare it to a weak edt quality wise. I have this scent in the mist and it smells like a peppery champagne with hints of freesia and vague, nondescript fruits.

Our carefully crafted bottle and sophisticated pump delivers great coverage while conditioning aloe mist nourishes skin for the lightest, most refreshing way to fragrance! Perhaps I got bored with it, perhaps my skin chemistry or sniffer has altered in some way that makes it less appealing to me. I should preface this by saying that lately I've been alternating scents like crazy (not all of the scents I alternate are bath and body works) and that I become obsessed with a scent for a small period of time and then move on. Not a surprise since BBW scents that are this weak and soft, tends not to last even if you layer them with oils or lotions.It's very luxurious, quite like a glass of champagne- I do detect a hint of it in this scent, but not in a bitter, alcohol way, it's very light and subtle. Layer this one with Demeter Fragrance Ginger Cookie (It cuts down the sweetness, whilst, keeping it Christmasy! This is going to sound insane but right off the bat of course you smell a nice fruity tone with no berries but citrus fruits, but it also smells incredibly earthy.