But even though the designs are similar, there are also some significant differences. The outer shell is different, the inner lining is different, and the sleeves are different. Let’s discuss these one by one. Outer Shell Difference Wind Fighter, Rain Defender, & Storm Defender Technology– Worried about the elements? These three types of Carhartt Technologies help defend you against wind and precipitation. Rain Defender is for light precipitation, and the Storm Defender is for heavier precipitation. If you find yourself in more extreme conditions – like really, really cold, you can also look into merino wool outer layers. I’ve written a bit on some merino wool brands. Now, even though the difference is simply the outer-shell fabric, that difference has several implications. Here are the main differences you need to consider when comparing Carhartt J140 vs J130: Just like Carhartt has a wide range of linings, they also offer a wide range of outer shell fabrics so that you can find one that is tough enough to handle what you are going to throw at it, but also has the comfort and flexibility you are looking for.

In my experience the Sandstone shell still has provided a small bit of water protection (but again, officially, it is not certified water-repellent). The result of the ring-spun approach is a stiff fabric that is extremely durable. It’s also a champion at protecting against weather conditions like wind or rain. However, the real deal is the brand’s Arctic-Quilt lining. And that’s exactly what the J133 Yukon has in store for you. Step 3: Decide if there are any type of extra features you will need to help you get the job done (full-swing, flame-resistant, wind-resistance, etc). Lining – This is where the major difference exists between the Carhartt J140 vs J131. The J140 has the quilted-flannel lining, which is Carhartt’s second warmest lining. The J131 has a thermal-fleece lining, which is one of Carhartt’s lightest linings. The J140 is built for cold-weather climates and the J131 is built for mild-winter climates.Again, I actually wear the J140 the most (firm shell) and the firm outer-shell doesn’t bother me, but you will need to decide if you’d rather have the firm shell, or the pre-washed Sandstone shell. Just like the Carhartt J140 vs J131 we discussed above, there are a lot of differences between the Carhartt J130 vs J131. Not only do they have different outer-shells, they are also built for different climates. Here’s what you need to know: Here are Carhartt’s available linings, and my personal opinion on how they rank from mild warmth to warmest. Just for reference, I would consider the thermal lining something I’d wear on a mild winter day: Carhartt Lining Here are Carhartt’s available linings, and my personal opinion on how they rank from lightweight warmth to warmest. Just for reference, I would consider the thermal lining something I’d wear on a mild winter day: Carhartt Lining

With the introduction taken care of, let’s take a closer look at these three Carhartt beauties. 🙂 Carhartt J130 vs J140: Update – As of 2021, Carhartt has replaced the J130 with an updated version which is style 104050. Just like the J130, this new version uses a pre-washed shell so that the canvas has more of a broken-in feeling on the first wear. But there are also some differences. To read more about this updated version, and how it compares to the J130, visit my article that compares the J130 vs 104050.I’ve seen a few people insist that the J140 is warmer than its sandstone counterpart. A commonly cited reason is the different lining, with the J140 having a special thermal lining.